Hello dear
Welcome To Michael's Pizzeria of Avon
At Michael's Pizzeria of Avon, a cherished gem in Avon-By-The-Sea, the love for authentic Italian cuisine shines through. Nestled at 526 Main St, this inviting pizzeria balances tradition and innovation with a menu that delights the senses. Their BBQ Chicken Ranch Pizza has garnered rave reviews, embodying the passion of the staff, particularly the standout service from Noah. With dishes that evoke fond memories—like the tender meatballs and eggplant rolatini—Michael's offers a nostalgic yet fresh dining experience. Locals and visitors alike celebrate the warm atmosphere and exceptional flavors that unite them around the table.
About
Michael's Pizzeria of Avon
Welcome to Michael's Pizzeria of Avon, a charming gem nestled at 526 Main St, Avon-By-The-Sea, NJ. This delightful eatery does more than just serve food; it serves joy on a plate. With a focus on traditional Italian flavors and a dedication to exceptional service, Michael's is quickly becoming a beloved destination for both locals and visitors alike.
What draws you in first is the heartwarming camaraderie of the staff, as highlighted by customer experiences. The owner and team are not just there to take orders but to create connections. Visitors have remarked on the welcoming atmosphere, especially the personable service from staff like Noah, who adds a friendly touch to your dining experience.
The menu at Michael's Pizzeria is a celebration of classic Italian cuisine, emphasizing quality ingredients and authentic flavors. Each dish tells a story, starting from their mouth-watering BBQ Chicken Ranch Pizza, which left a lasting impression on customer Tim Kelly. To him, it was more than a meal; it was a jackpot experience. Many patrons, like Robert Hansen, equate the pizza to the nostalgic slices from their Brooklyn roots, underlining its authenticity.
- Enticing Sides: Complement your meal with delectable sides like Garlic Bread, Meatballs, and Sautéed Broccoli, perfect for sharing or savoring solo.
- Hearty Entrees: The Rigatoni Bolognese is a standout, featuring slow-cooked meat that envelops your palate with rich flavors. Paired with salad and toasted bread, it embodies comfort dining.
- Special Deals: Don’t miss their lunch specials, providing great value like the 1/2 Sandwich or Plain Slice Lunch Special, perfect for a midday recharge.
For those seeking a quick bite after a beach day, Michael's offers takeout options, and customers rave about the meatballs and eggplant rolatini, which are described as some of the best around. Kim Isaga found that her family's love for the food made for a memorable beach photo session, and even her teenager couldn't resist sneaking cold slices at 2 AM!
Whether you're a local or just passing through, a visit to Michael's Pizzeria of Avon promises to be more than just a meal. It's an experience where community and flavor unite, making every bite a testament to the essence of traditional Italian cooking. So, grab your loved ones, head to Avon-By-The-Sea, and treat yourself to a culinary adventure that you won't soon forget!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Hit the jackpot at Michael’s Pizzeria! Treated myself to a BBQ Chicken Ranch Pizza, and man oh man that jawn was tasty. Also was warmly welcomed by Noah (pictured). If you see him in here, expect some of the best customer service from the big guy. I love Michael’s Pizzeria, wish I had another star to give in my review. ”
“ No idea what people are talking about on here. The pizza was great... it's not Midwestern trash style pizza with 50 tons of mozz. it's the closest I've had to what I great up eating. Owner was friendly... again, I have no clue what people are talking about. I think it's the area... something about Avon. ”
“ Been living at the Jersey Shore for 16 yrs.Recently discoved Micheals.Its the best Pizza I've had in many years.Being from Brooklyn,I can say, this reminds me of the Pizza I grew up with.The Staff is excellent. ”
“ Ordered 4 XL pies last night for a group of family members taking pictures on the beach. All 15 people loved the pizza and my teenage son was having second helpings, cold, out of refrigerator at 2am. He can’t decide now if it’s better hot or cold so we will have to go back for more testing. The owners and staff were working hard and very personable. Thanks for a great dinner! ”
“ I decided to get some takeout after my beach day and I was pleasantly surprised about how delicious the food was!! I have to say it was some of the best meatballs I’ve ever had....they were soft and delicious. The eggplant rolatini was also very good. Now I where to go after my beach days when I’m craving Italian ”
“ The pizza is fantastic and one of the only places you can get it by the slice reasonably priced delicious salads everything we have tried is fantastic. We highly recommend you give it a try next time you're in town and definitely if you're a local. Mk ”
“ Best Pizza in the area and the area is filled with some of the best pizza in the US ”
“ In my opinion, this is this best Brooklyn style pizza in the area. The pizza tastes excellent and the crust is always tasty and crunchy. I have had their pizza about 8 times over the last 4 months and the quality has been very consistent. And the staff is very friendly, too. Order with confidence and enjoy! ”